How to Create a Highlight Reel That Captures a College Coach’s Attention
Too often, athletes and their families put together highlight reels that feel more like documentaries than recruitment tools. While it’s tempting to tell your full story or show every aspect of your journey, this approach isn’t effective when trying to get the attention of college coaches and scouts. Highlight reels need to be short, impactful, and focused solely on showcasing your talent as an athlete.
Understand the Coach’s Perspective
College coaches have limited time and often sift through hundreds of highlight reels. They’re not looking for an emotional narrative, they’re looking for talent. The key question to ask yourself is, “If a coach watches this, will it capture their attention in the first 15 seconds?” If not, they’ll likely move on to the next prospect.
Avoid Common Mistakes
Here are some of the most frequent errors athletes make when creating their highlight reels:
Non-Game Footage: Clips of warming up, traveling to games, pumping up the crowd, or shooting around in an empty gym are unnecessary. Coaches are not looking for behind-the-scenes content, they’re looking for how you perform in competitive situations.
Dragging Openers: Avoid starting your video with a slow buildup or dramatic intro. This isn’t a feature film. Coaches don’t want to wait to see what you can do.
No Clear Focus: Highlight reels that lack a clear purpose or showcase too many average plays dilute their impact.
Start Strong
The first 10-15 seconds are crucial. Begin with your most impressive, game-relevant plays, ones that immediately illustrate your strengths as a player. For example:
If you’re a basketball player, show a dynamic dunk in traffic, a clutch three-pointer, or excellent defensive hustle.
If you’re a soccer player, highlight a well-executed goal, a precise assist, or a critical defensive play.
If you’re a football player, show a game-changing pass, tackle, or touchdown.
Your goal is to make an immediate impact, leaving no doubt about what you bring to the table.
Keep It Game-Centric
Every clip in your highlight reel should be from actual competition. Coaches want to see how you perform against real opponents, not how high you can jump in an empty gym. The context of the play matters whether it’s the score, the situation, or the quality of the opposition because it shows how you respond in meaningful moments.
Keep It Short and Focused
Highlight reels don’t need to be long. In fact, a video that runs 2-3 minutes is ideal. Anything longer risks losing the coach’s interest. Choose your best 8-12 plays and arrange them thoughtfully. There’s no need for a dramatic ending or a “climax” to your reel—if they’re impressed by the first few plays, they’ll stick around.
Final Tips
Include your name, position, and contact information at the start and end of the video. Make it easy for coaches to follow up.
Use clear video footage with no distracting music or effects.
If you’re showcasing multiple skills, group similar clips together for clarity.
By focusing on what matters most, you’ll create a highlight reel that grabs attention and keeps it. Remember, you’re not making a documentary; you’re giving coaches a reason to dig a lot further into you as a recruit.
Thank you for reading Five Star University, access our free webinar here.